Six Reasons People Repeat Painful Experiences
People seek pleasure and avoid pain, but it’s not that simple.
Psychotherapists have long observed that people repeat and relive their most painful experiences. Freud called it the “repetition compulsion.” Why do we do this? Here are six reasons.
1. To alleviate guilt
Some people feel guilty about success or pleasure, as if enjoyment were a transgression. They seek suffering to expiate guilt and appease their conscience. In some cases, pain and suffering become the “admission price” for whatever pleasure they allow themselves.
2. To gain a sense of control and mastery
The person attempts to gain a sense of control over painful or traumatic experiences they once endured helplessly. There is an underlying (unconscious) fantasy that they can undo a past hurt or right a past wrong, by repeating it and getting it to come out differently. But the tragic reality is that they keep reliving the same pain.
3. Because suffering is home
When panicked horses are rescued from a burning stable, they often run right back in. The horses associate the stable with safety and security—it’s their home. Likewise, a child’s earliest attachments, however painful, are home. However neglectful or abusive, that was where they experienced whatever care and comfort they knew. In their search for comfort, they return to the same pain.
4. For secondary gain
Mental health symptoms often come with hidden benefits, known to clinicians as “secondary gain.” These may include attention, sympathy, release from responsibility, special treatment, even financial incentives (e.g., disability pay). Secondary gain can be a powerful incentive for continued suffering.
In psychotherapy, it’s useful to invite patients to consider the downside of getting well. The first response is often, “There is no downside, I’d do anything to get better.” But if the therapist persists and creates space for reflection—“Not so fast, let’s really think about this”—surprising answers can surface.
5. To punish others (passive-aggression)
The desire to punish someone can be more powerful than the desire to avoid pain. A person may sabotage their own prospects for success or happiness simply because it’s what someone else wants for them (hence the expression, “cutting off your nose to spite your face”).
Mental health symptoms often cause pain and suffering for others. A depressed person may be too depressed to do their share of work, earn a living, keep commitments, have sex with their partner, and so on. There can be (often unconscious) sadistic pleasure in punishing others, especially when done without responsibility or consequences. After all, who would blame the victim?
6. To enhance self esteem or feel superior
For some, self-worth—and even a sense of superiority—is rooted in self-deprivation and suffering. They seem organized around the belief, I’m better than you because I suffer more. The greater the hardship, the greater their feeling of moral superiority. Psychoanalysts call this moral masochism.
So now you know some of the reasons. One caveat: there are rarely conscious choices. Our self-defeating patterns most often play out unconsciously.
More essays, interviews, clips, and reflections at my Linktree:
linktr.ee/jonathanshedler