Why AI Can’t Replicate Psychotherapy

The conditions that make real therapy possible can’t be scraped, modeled, or faked.

Okay, tech bros. I know you love your AI, and it can do really cool stuff. But you need to understand something:

You don’t know shit about psychotherapy. You’re not trained in it. You’ve probably never met a psychotherapist with real expertise.

I can already hear your response. We don’t have to be experts. That’s the beauty of LLMs. They’re trained on data from therapy sessions and learn the thinking and responses of experts. That’s what we model.

Except you don’t and you can’t. And if you understood a few things about legitimate psychotherapy, you would know why you can’t.

For real psychotherapy to happen—for patients to unclench and truly reveal themselves—certain conditions must exist. Psychotherapists call this the therapy “frame.”

And the first and most basic element of the therapy frame is absolute, inviolable, non-negotiable privacy and confidentiality. It’s sacred.

Compromise that and everything changes. It’s no longer the real deal. It becomes a hollow imitation. Real psychotherapy is over.

Compromise the therapy frame and everything changes. It’s no longer the real deal. It becomes a hollow imitation. Real psychotherapy is over.

Every expert understands this, and well-trained psychotherapists internalize it.

And here’s the thing: no expert psychotherapist will allow their sessions to be recorded and uploaded to your database. No way, no how. Never.

You cannot get that data.

It would be a betrayal of the patient and the psychotherapy process at a fundamental level. Even with patient consent. And an expert psychotherapist would never ask for that consent, because they understand what’s at stake.

You know what else? Even if somehow, in some hypothetical parallel universe, you could get expert therapists to give you access, it still wouldn’t help you.

Because it would fundamentally alter the therapy relationship and what can happen in it.

Here’s the paradox:

Expert therapists will never let you in. Only poorly-trained therapists—who don’t grasp the essence of psychotherapy—will give you access.

Alternatively, you may get access to therapists who are providing something more like didactic “skills training” or guided self-help. There’s a place for that, but it’s a different animal entirely.

Your training data will come from non-experts providing superficial, bad therapy.

The only thing AI can model is mediocrity.

---

More essays, interviews, clips, and reflections at my Linktree