Therapists Say the Relationship Heals. Few Know What It Means.
The relationship heals, but only if the therapist knows how to use it.
Upcoming workshop: I’ll be leading a full-day clinical case discussion workshop on April 25: Treating Challenging Patients: From Case Formulation to Shared Treatment Focus. Open to clinicians and trainees worldwide via Zoom.
Student rates available. Early Bird registration now open.
We repeat relationship patterns throughout our lives. Our earliest attachments become unconscious templates for later relationships. Because they’ve always been with us, they can be as invisible to us as water to a fish.
Psychotherapy is a relationship too, and patients inevitably bring their patterns with them. As psychotherapists, we enter the gravitational pull of our patients’ self-defeating relationship patterns and experience them in real time. When we recognize our own participation, we can help our patients understand the patterns they’re caught in—and begin to free themselves.
This is how psychotherapy changes lives. This is the heart of psychoanalytic therapy.
Veronica, in her late 30s, is elegant and accomplished. She carries herself with a regal bearing and looks like a Vogue model. She gets pursued by the kind of men most women only fantasize about. Yet she is lonely. She has never been able to keep an intimate relationship, and she suffers from chronic low-grade depression.
Veronica has attempted therapy several times. She says it never changed anything, and the therapists always ended up wanting her approval.
Few therapists attach real significance to Veronica’s comments. Some suggest she needs a secure therapist who won’t be intimidated by her looks or status.
These therapists miss what makes psychotherapy transformative. Whether her therapist is personally secure or insecure is irrelevant. What she needs is a therapist with the self-awareness and courage to notice the twinge of insecurity they feel in her presence, recognize it as vital information, and use it constructively to help her see what she has not seen before.
Such a therapist might say: “You know, you have come here for my help and yet in many of our interactions, I’m aware of a vague feeling of wanting to impress you or gain your approval—which doesn’t help you at all. I’m trying to understand what it means, and whether it might shed some light on what happens in your other relationships. Perhaps something about this feels familiar to you.”
That’s where real psychotherapy begins: with an invitation to notice what is happening here and now.
What the patient does in the room with the therapist reveals their lifelong relationship patterns.
Veronica cannot tell her therapist what goes wrong in her relationships because she doesn’t know. Instead, she shows him by recreating her patterns in the therapy relationship. The things she does to draw others closer—reflexively maneuvering for status—are the very things that keep them at a distance. Women become envious or deferential. Men see her as a conquest or out of their league. Either way, genuine intimacy is impossible.
What the patient does in the room with the therapist reveals their lifelong relationship patterns. That’s where they can finally be recognized, understood, and potentially changed.
This is central to psychoanalytic therapy—and often absent from other approaches.
A prominent CBT thought leader wrote about myths and realities of CBT. She said it’s a myth that CBT downplays the therapy relationship. To counter it, she noted that CBT therapists “do many things to build a strong alliance. For example, they work collaboratively with clients… ask for feedback… and conduct themselves as genuine, warm, empathic, interested, caring human beings.”
I expect that much from my hair stylist or real estate agent. From a psychotherapist, I expect more. The thought leader showed no recognition that the psychotherapy relationship offers a window into a patient’s relationship patterns and inner world—and can become a living relationship laboratory where lifelong patterns are recognized, explored, and reworked.
Some patients may be satisfied with therapists who “work collaboratively” while providing the same tools and interventions to all.
But those who want to change their lives will need a psychotherapist with the awareness, knowledge, and courage to see and name what the patient cannot.
Related Essays
Getting Started in Psychotherapy: A Guide for Patients (and Their Therapists)
(September 3, 2025)When the Real Reason for Therapy Finally Surfaces
(October 27, 2025)Much of What Is Called Therapy Is Not Psychotherapy (February 23, 2026)
April 25 workshop information and registration available here.
More writing, interviews, and related work on my Linktree.
Thanks for writing this so precisely and concisely. In psychoanalytic therapy, the relationship itself is “in therapy” and client and therapist have an opportunity to study and inquire into what is otherwise unknown and unspeakable in walking-around life. An extraordinary opportunity for real-life investigation in an optimal space. Many therapists, especially those trained in CBT and various relational approaches, neither understand nor know how to operate therapeutically in the psychoanalytic deconstruction of our defenses. I have always appreciated your analyses and reports. I will use this article in supervising psychiatric residents because it is brief and clear! Really appreciate this clarity.
This captures something many clients sense but can’t articulate: the relationship is not just supportive, it’s diagnostic and transformative when used skillfully. The example with Veronica shows how subtle dynamics in the room carry more truth than any self-report ever could. It takes real self-awareness for a therapist to notice their own reactions without defensiveness and turn that into insight rather than acting it out. That level of attunement is rare and it makes all the difference.